Our Insurance Carriers
Claims & Payments Information
Insurance Claims and Services
As a Mills Insurance Services personal insurance policy holder you have the option of contacting our agency at 800-391-2056 during business hours or directly contact your carrier below 24 hours a day.
| Company | Main Claims | Billing |
| Safeco Insurance Co. of America | 866-472-3326 | 866-472-3326 |
| Hartford Insurance | 800-243-5860 | 800-771-8557 |
| Mercury Insurance Group | 800-503-3724 | 888-637-2176 |
| Progressive | 800-776-4737 | 800-300-3693 |
| Travelers | 800-252-4633 | 800-550-7716 |
| Allied | 800-282-1446 | 800-282-1446 |
| Stillwater | 800-220-1351 | 800-849-6140 |
| Infinity | 800-334-1661 | 800-782-1330 |
| Kemper | 888-253-7834 | 888-834-7780 |
| Foremost | 800-527-3907 | 800-532-4221 |
| First American Specialty | 800-348-3782 | 888-474-7500 |
| Commerce West | 800-244-1545 | 800-244-1545 |
| Mapfre Claims | 866-351-2548 | 800-244-1545 |
| CSE Insurance | 800-282-6848 |
